Two Cautiously and One in Brief...

Music and Libretto by Stephen Schwartz
Based on the novel by Mark McShane
and the screenplay by Bryan Forbes
Directed by Scott Schwartz
Starring Laura Flanagan and Kim Josephson
A Production of New York City Opera
at Lincoln Center
Seance Website

Music by Alan Menken
Lyrics by Glenn Slater
Book by Cheri & Bill Steinkellner
Additional Book Material by Douglas Carter Beane
Based on the screenplay by Joseph Howard
Directed by Jerry Zaks
Starring Patina Miller and Victoria Clark
Broadway Theatre
Sister Act Website

Book by Rupert Holmes
Music by John Kander
Lyrics by Fred Ebb
Original Book and Concept by Peter Stone
Additional Lyrics by John Kander and Rupert Holmes
Directed by Mark S. Hoebee
Starring Robert Newman and Kim Zimmer
Paper Mill Playhouse
in Millburn, NJ

Reviewed and not-reviewed by David Spencer

I’ve never had a strict “conflict of interest” policy; I’ve always let instinct guide me when productions involve collaborators of mine, people I know in a context that’s particularly nuanced, and/or having seen a production under circumstances that would behoove me to behave more like a guest than a critic. And with regard to both Sister Act and Séance on a Wet Afternoon, instinct tells me to default to my best compromise: the review that isn’t really a review. I wouldn’t even write that much about most such pieces that left me with a negative impression (I say most because I’d hate for silence always to be inferred as de facto disapproval), so the fact that I’m mentioning these shows at all constitutes an unambiguous endorsement of both.

                  Were I to write about Stephen Schwartz’ opera in serious detail, I suppose my opinion would fall into the mixed-positive category, for reasons I won’t detail. But I will tell you that it’s a substantial and very worthwhile work, that represents the concept “creative risk” at its best, managing to be both a renegade stretch for its author while remaining accessibly expressed, with a clear narrative and a score of some power and beauty. The after-show discussions it engenders are passionate and mixed (which seems appropriate) but it absolutely “knows its own mind” and hits the target it means to hit. Which alone makes it worth seeing. How you may feel about it I can’t predict, but I can say you won’t feel your time was in any way wasted.

                  Sister Act, based on the popular comedy film of the same name, just flat out seeks to be a crowd-pleaser, and is very successful at it. (I know more than a few who liked it better than The Book of Mormon). This one too hits its target toward a much less equivocal response, after-show controversy relegated to the slickness of the package, and how much actual heart may exist at the core (to disclose just a little on a personal, rather than analytical, note: through Act One I wondered, but through Act Two I was swept along). But again, it’s one of the season’s shows you can feel good about having attended, whether to simply revel in its energy (which seems to be the majority response) or stock up on energy for a post-show debate.

                  I can however, give a fully committed review of the new production of Curtains, the Kander-Ebb-Holmes-Stone backstage murder-mystery musical currently in regional revival at the Paper Mill Playhouse. For a detailed analysis of the show proper, and what I still, by and large think of it, you can see my review of the Broadway production here.

                  But to talk simply of the new production itself, director Mark S. Hoebee has made things a little lighter and brighter than they were on Broadway, which helps the material, which is on its own terms very respectable without being extraordinary, a good deal. The arguably “gimmick” casting of two soap stars from the same daytime drama in the show’s lead roles—Robert Newman and Kim Zimmer who are both approximately quarter-century veterans of The Guiding Light (which ended its run in 2009)—proves both a PR coup and a delightful surprise for any who haven’t seen them onstage before: for each is excellent at comedy both light and broad, and equally proficient at delivering musical theatre. (I daresay too that anyone seeing them onstage without having seen them on the soap would be amazed that performers with that much high octane exuberance could sustain anything as contained and camera-constrained as a character in a daytime drama). The rest of the cast is as impressive, including Helen Anker, Ed Dixon, Anne Horak, my old friend and occasional performer of my work Daniel Marcus and veteran of the Broadway company David Elder, among as many equally terrific supporting players and a top notch singing-dancing ensemble. Add to this Broadway-savvy choreography by Joann M. Hunter and a fine design team, and Curtains is…well, how shall I put this…about as good as it can be. Which for a lightweight night out is good enough.

Go to David Spencer's Profile
Return to Home Page

  • Road (National) Tour Review Index
  • New York City & Environs Theatre Review Index
  • Berkshire, Massachusetts Theatre Review Index
  • Boston Area Theatre Review Index
  • Florida Theatre Review Index
  • Minneapolis/St. Paul (Twin Cities) Theatre Review Index
  • Philadelphia & Environs Theatre Review Index
  • San Francisco Bay Area Theatre Review Index
  • Seattle Area Theatre Review Index
  • Toronto, Ontario (Canada) Index